Apr 10 2011
EXPERIENCE TRUMPS EXPERTISE
If you don’t know how to
apply what you know,
you know nothing!
I saw some guest blog post somewhere today that made me laugh out loud because it naively proclaims that “expertise trumps experience” and then proceeds to flex 20-something-years-old muscle with empty rants and raves about Internet skills, from blogging to SEO and beyond.
Not being one to let sleeping dogs lie, I submit the following for your consideration:
-
Younger generations have quite literally constellations worth of knowledge to offer to any given situation.
-
They are born of Google and Microsoft and American Idol and Harry Potter. They are filled with energy drinks that make a cup of coffee seem like Darvon.
-
We rickity old antique types watch high performance skateboarders, or teenage text message thumbs at work in astonishment — young people ooze skills that older people could never even have dreamed of possessing.
-
And I do once remember hearing, at age 32, that I was “older than dirt” from a 21-year-old who was quite serious at the time.
Yet something tugs at my sleeve. Is it per chance that discarded old notion of respect for experience?
Perhaps the tugging is because experience is almost necessarily a product of quiet reflection while “expertise” practically requires a shout from the rooftops to get the attention of others.
Maybe I live in fantasyland, but it seems to me that –other than some phenom celebrity types: Justin and Hanna? Or the dudes who invented Twitter and Facebook– there’s really no one on that horizon of greatness that once ushered in Bill Gates and Steven Jobs.
Ah, but then this isn’t about comparing generations.
It’s about the fact that expertise means absolutely nothing if you don’t have the experience base to know how to use it productively.
No need to look much beyond the world of professional sports for a few hundred perfect examples.
The Internet? Well, aside from Al Gore’s claims to have once invented it, I believe that the “expertise” involved is in fact not with any single age or experience group, and research –even that which is distorted by Internet industry research leaders– is aptly underpinned with total age diversity in the expertise of blogging to SEO and beyond.
Ah, but then this isn’t about the Internet either, really. It’s all about the fact that regardless of all the wonderful online skills in one’s possession, not having a way to get paid for exercising them –because of lack of experience– also means absolutely nothing.
And there’s no need to look much beyond the artificial unemployment figures being cast about by self-serving politicians, who trickle on down from the White House, to clearly see a few million examples.
_____________________
THE BOTTOM LINE:
Expertise (whatever that means, and from whatever sources declare themselves to possess it) is simply a specialized knowledge base of how things happen or function.
Experience is knowing how to put that knowledge base to work to get results.
It’s pretty silly to be trying to make a case for one at the expense of the other.
Posts RSS Feed FREE Blog Subscription
# # #
302.933.0116 Hal@BusinessWorks.US
Thanks for visiting. Go for your goals! God Bless You.
“The price of freedom is eternal vigilance!” [Thomas Jefferson]